Home Philosophy The Eternal Trap and the Idea of Human Freedom

The Eternal Trap and the Idea of Human Freedom

3
The Eternal Trap and the Idea of Human Freedom

We love the idea of freedom, but freedom does not come without straps. In other words, we are trapped.

Is man free? And if he is free, how much freedom he has?  If he is not free, is he trapped as soon as he is born? Was he free prior to his entry into the womb of his mother?

Dr. Jernail S. Anand

When a rat walks into a trap,

It has no idea what has happened.

When it realizes it is trapped.

It is devastated.

 

Men so long as they think they are free,

Behave like victors.

What happens when they realize

Even this freedom is a trap?

 

A kind soul takes pity on the rat

And releases it from the trap,

Where it thinks it is free

Unaware of the cat on killer spree.

 

When the procession took a turn

Towards the ruins,

I thought now I would be free

But death too was a part of divine trapestry.

THE PRISON SYNDROME

Freedom is a wonderful word, which has always captured the imagination of mankind. In fact, the struggle that the centuries have seen, was marked by two conflicting forces: the spirit to dominate, crush and exploit, and the spirit to get free of systems inimical to man’s essential freedom. Freedom has always been the cherished dream of mankind. But, when we turn our gaze from the political to the existential plane, we are faced with some disturbing questions.

pexels-pixabay-247851Is man free? And if he is free, how much freedom he has?  If he is not free, is he trapped as soon as he is born? Was he free prior to his entry into the womb of his mother? Was he flying as a free agent in the air, when he was trapped by his parents into life? If Life is a trap, will Death help us walk out of it?  In fact, I am talking of the Prison Syndrome which dominates human existence. Animals, when tied to the tether, or birds when put into cages, realize they had lost an invisible ‘charm’ called freedom. Now, they cannot move at will. Similarly, men too suffer from the prison syndrome. However, we give it a respectable nomenclature: limitations of being human.

Human beings suffer from this trap psychology. Freedom is a fantasy. It is an illusion because, when we are born, we are shifted from one trap to another trap. Life is a movement of sorts inside a trap, and finally, we are further let off into a trap which appears to be without borders. The rat who walks into a trap, when brought to freedom, also runs the risk of cats or death by brickbats.

Human beings suffer from this trap psychology. Freedom is a fantasy. It is an illusion because, when we are born, we are shifted from one trap to another trap.

Political scientists make great hullabaloo when they talk of Freedom. Freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of life etc. – all these are high sounding words. But there is nothing called absolute freedom which might mean chaos. Words like freedom, order, chaos, disorder come together. As such, when we talk of freedom, we have to talk of discipline too which is mandatory.  This freedom has its basis in our commitment to essential discipline of the society. Give a train the freedom to move in any direction. It will not be able to clear out of the zigzag of the platform itself.  Thus, ‘Discipline’ is a very polite name for limitations, again an acceptable face of the prison syndrome.

f5529885d921ca3510d8e8d81e578fd8 Pinterest Featured image
Image courtesy: Pinterest
THE TRAPPED

We love the idea of freedom, but freedom does not come without straps. In other words, we are trapped. Womb was a trap. And then, life is a trap. A man who is sent to prison, knows why he is in the prison and for how long. But, in case of men, no one knows how long the prison term is.  Whatever we do, is seriously controlled by our conditions, our milieu, our society, our traditions and our aspirations. Breaking out of these ‘traps’ is next to impossible.

Moreover, every man is circumscribed by his nature and by the external circumstances. You have feet, but how long can you walk?  You have arms. But how long they can be extended? The very construction of man has ingrained limitations of its own. Just as a ball which when kicked, goes up to a certain height and then takes U turn, men too are powered with a measured fuel, and they cannot go beyond a certain limit. Our voice has a limit. Our silence has a limit. Our patience has a limit.  This limit is the trap I am talking about. We cannot go beyond it. If we try to speak louder than we can, or listen to things which are not audible, or know things which we should not otherwise know, it is trespassing into the domain of the forbidden. Knowledge was forbidden. You know what happened when it was trespassed. This is how we are trapped in a destiny. We are free to operate, just like a bird left free in a house. It flies up and down, but cannot find an outlet. We forget, this body lays down our limits. Our mind lays down the limits of our understanding. The entire world is lying open before us, just as an ocean is spread before a thirsty man. Yet, can he drink every drop of it? He has a limit to digest water, take in air, and eat, though 36 types of dishes are waiting on the table.

Freedom - Eternalized
Freedom. Image courtesy: Eternalized
THE TRAP OF HUMAN DESTINY

Finally, I would like to say, we are trapped in a destiny. And to trudge out of it, is a difficult proposition. Those who can peep into the future, are usually blind. Those who can look into the past of a person, are usually abnormal men, unfit for human society. If we remember Lear, he transcended the limits of filial responsibility. And suffered. So was Macbeth. He could have escaped the disaster that overtook him, if he had realized his limits. Lady Macbeth who broke the limits of feminine grace, kills herself by swallowing fire. Those who break the rules of human grace, come to grief. Man who learns to respect his destiny, who realizes what can be done and how it should be done, is often the person who knows the art of synchronizing with the divine will and understands the secret of graceful living.

Read: Poetry is not a Romantic Luxury – Dr. Jernail Singh Anand

___________________

Jernail S Anand - Sindh CourierDr. Jernail Singh Anand, President of the International Academy of Ethics, is author of 161 books in English poetry, fiction, non-fiction, philosophy and spirituality. He was awarded Charter of Morava, the great Award by Serbian Writers Association, Belgrade and his name was engraved on the Poets’ Rock in Serbia. The Academy of Arts and philosophical Sciences of Bari [Italy] honored him with the award of an Honorable Academic.  Recently, he was awarded Doctor of Philosophy [Honoris Causa] by the University of Engg and Management, Jaipur. Recently, he organized an International Conference on Contemporary Ethics at Chandigarh. His most phenomenal book is Lustus: The Prince of Darkness [first epic of the Mahkaal Trilogy]. Email: anandjs55@yahoo.com

Link Bibliography:

https://atunispoetry.com/2023/12/08/indian-author-dr-jernail-s-anand-honoured-at-the-60th-belgrade-international-meeting-of-writers/

 

 

 

 

3 COMMENTS

  1. I read the article and I agree with the idea that everyone and everything has its limits, but I have to admit that throughout history and nowadays, there were always those that considered themselves gods and forced limitations so that they can control and exploit people. In the present days, according to a psychologist from Belgium, many prefer to be slaves and to suffer than fight for what they believe in and for their freedom. Sigmund Freud once said that humanity will never be completely free because the majority is afraid of being responsible for their own lives. From my point of view, most people dislike thinking, responsibility, looking within themselves, knowledge, the truth and reality because they’re a threat to their illusions and lies, and they can no longer control, manipulate and exploit others. The article itself reminded me of one of Aldous Huxley’s quotes that predicted the so-called democracy of today:
    “The perfect dictatorship would have the appearance of a democracy, but would basically be a prison without walls in which the prisoners would not even dream of escaping. It would essentially be a system of slavery where, through consumption and entertainment, the slaves would love their servitudes.”

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here