Sindh’s fishermen feed nations but starve at home. They earn foreign exchange but live without rights. Their children are born into poverty and, today, are even being imprisoned across borders.
This is not just a maritime or diplomatic issue—it is a moral test.
Dr. Mazhar Lakho | USA
The fishing community of Sindh is one of the oldest and most neglected segments of Pakistan’s coastal society. From the creeks of the Indus Delta to the open waters of the Arabian Sea, thousands of Sindhi fishermen depend entirely on the sea for survival. Fishing is not merely an occupation for them; it is a way of life passed down through generations. Yet, despite contributing significantly to food security, exports, and the coastal economy, Sindh’s fishermen remain among the poorest, most vulnerable, and most voiceless citizens of the country.
Sindh’s coastline stretches over 350 kilometers, and areas such as Ibrahim Hyderi, Rehri Goth, Keti Bandar, Shah Bandar, Jati, and Kharo Chan form the backbone of Pakistan’s marine fishing industry. Karachi’s fish harbors alone handle a major portion of national seafood exports. Shrimp, pomfret, tuna, and other marine species harvested by these fishermen earn valuable foreign exchange for the country. Ironically, those who generate this wealth live in extreme deprivation—without clean drinking water, healthcare, quality education, or basic social protection.
Poverty, Debt, and Child Labor
Most fishermen operate small, unsafe boats and rely on middlemen for fuel, nets, and supplies. This creates a cycle of debt bondage, where entire families are trapped economically. Due to crushing poverty, children often accompany their fathers to sea from a very young age. This is not a choice, but a survival strategy. These children should be in schools, not on fishing boats navigating dangerous waters and international maritime fault lines.
Arrests, Detentions, and a Human Rights Crisis
The recent capture of 11 poor fishermen from Ibrahim Hyderi, Karachi, by the Indian Navy—two of whom are children around ten years old—is a painful reminder of a long-standing humanitarian crisis. Sindhi fishermen are frequently arrested while fishing in deep sea waters, where maritime boundaries are neither clearly marked nor technologically visible to small, ill-equipped boats.
These fishermen are not smugglers, spies, or criminals. They are illiterate, impoverished civilians chasing fish stocks that have steadily declined closer to shore due to pollution, overfishing by trawlers, and climate change. Many have been languishing in Indian prisons for years, separated from their families, with no access to timely legal aid. This is a chronic breach of basic human rights, and the detention of children is especially indefensible under international humanitarian and child protection laws.
At the very least, innocent children must be released immediately and unconditionally. There can be no justification—legal, moral, or political—for imprisoning children whose only “crime” is poverty.
Environmental Destruction and Policy Failure
Sindh’s fishing industry is also collapsing due to large-scale environmental degradation. The Indus Delta is shrinking rapidly because of reduced freshwater flows, mangrove destruction, and unchecked industrial pollution. Illegal deep-sea trawling, often by powerful interests, has devastated fish breeding grounds, forcing small fishermen to venture farther into dangerous waters—making arrests by foreign navies more likely.
State policy has consistently failed Sindh’s fishermen. There is little investment in modern navigation tools, safety equipment, or legal awareness. No effective social safety nets exist for families when breadwinners are arrested or lost at sea. Compensation, if any, is symbolic and delayed.
The Role of the Fishermen Cooperative Society and the State
The Fishermen Cooperative Society (FCS) must rise above bureaucratic inertia and act as a true representative of fishermen’s interests. This issue should be taken up at the highest diplomatic level immediately, with an urgent demand for the release of all detained fishermen, especially children. Regular, structured diplomatic mechanisms between Pakistan and India must be activated to ensure speedy repatriation, as has been done in the past.
The Government of Pakistan and the Government of Sindh must:
- Establish rapid legal and diplomatic response cells for arrested fishermen
- Provide modern GPS and boundary-awareness tools to fishing boats
- Enforce strict bans on destructive trawling
- Invest in education, healthcare, and alternative livelihoods for coastal communities
- Treat fishermen as citizens deserving dignity, not disposable labor
Conclusion
Sindh’s fishermen feed nations but starve at home. They earn foreign exchange but live without rights. Their children are born into poverty and, today, are even being imprisoned across borders. This is not just a maritime or diplomatic issue—it is a moral test.
If the state cannot protect its poorest citizens, especially its children, then all claims of justice and sovereignty ring hollow. The fishermen of Sindh deserve protection, respect, and immediate action—not silence, neglect, and prison cells across the sea.
_________________
