The decline in the quality of higher education is a multifaceted problem that requires comprehensive reform
- Universities must realign their priorities, placing academic excellence above financial considerations
By Dr. Mahmood Laghari
The pursuit of quality education is the cornerstone of any academic institution. However, a troubling trend has emerged in some universities, where the focus on financial sustainability has inadvertently led to the deterioration of academic standards. This systemic issue, rooted in flawed admissions practices and inadequate support structures, threatens the very essence of higher education. This article delves into the underlying causes, the cascading effects on the academic ecosystem, and actionable recommendations to address these challenges.
Compromised admissions standards
The first link in the chain of declining quality begins with the admissions process. Many universities prioritize filling allocated seats to sustain their financial operations. While the intention is to maintain the university’s revenue stream, this approach often results in admitting students who do not meet the established merit criteria. These students struggle academically, leading to repeated failures in courses and the need for multiple attempts to pass examinations. This compromises the academic rigor of the institution and sets a precedent where mediocrity is tolerated, if not encouraged.
The ripple effect in advanced degrees
The ramifications of lenient undergraduate admissions extend to postgraduate programs. Graduates who have benefited from this leniency often proceed to enroll in masters and doctoral programs. Financial stability allows them to bypass regular academic engagement, treating their studies as a part-time endeavor while focusing on private businesses or jobs. PhD students, in particular, often face the dual burden of supporting themselves financially and pursuing their research without adequate institutional support. The lack of funding for research projects further diminishes the quality of their academic output, leading to theses that lack originality, rigor, and practical application.
Faculty overload and neglect
The shortage of qualified faculty exacerbates the problem. Overburdened professors, tasked with handling large undergraduate classes, often deprioritize postgraduate teaching and research supervision. This creates a vicious cycle where postgraduate students, already disengaged from their studies, receive minimal guidance and mentorship. The result is a generation of scholars who lack basic laboratory skills, writing proficiency, and the ability to present and defend their work effectively.
Read: Fostering Creativity in Pakistan’s Universities
The long-term consequences
Perhaps the most alarming outcome of this flawed system is the infiltration of poorly trained PhD holders into academic positions. These individuals, leveraging their degrees, secure visiting or volunteer teaching roles that eventually transition into permanent faculty positions. Over time, this perpetuates a culture of mediocrity within academia, undermining the credibility of institutions and producing graduates ill-equipped to meet the demands of the professional world.
Read: The Dire State Of Higher Education In Pakistan
Urgent solutions for systemic reform
Addressing these challenges requires immediate and sustained efforts at multiple levels. The following recommendations aim to restore the integrity and quality of higher education:
- Revise admissions policies: Admissions should be based strictly on merit, with supplementary remedial programs for borderline candidates. This ensures that only capable and motivated students enter the system.
- Provide financial support: Institutions must allocate dedicated funding for postgraduate research. Scholarships, grants, and stipends can alleviate the financial burden on students, enabling them to focus fully on their studies.
- Strengthen faculty resources: Recruit additional faculty to reduce the workload and ensure that both undergraduate and postgraduate students receive adequate attention. Faculty development programs should also be introduced to enhance teaching and research capabilities.
- Implement accountability measures: Establish strict monitoring and evaluation mechanisms for postgraduate programs. Regular assessments of student progress and faculty engagement can help maintain high standards.
- Foster industry collaboration: Partner with industries to provide funding, internships, and real-world research opportunities for students. This ensures that research is aligned with practical applications and societal needs.
- Enhance academic rigor: Enforce stringent criteria for coursework, examinations, and thesis evaluations. Proper external reviewers and standardized benchmarks can help uphold academic quality.
- Promote a culture of excellence: Recognize and reward academic achievements among students and faculty. Encouraging healthy competition and celebrating scholarly excellence can inspire a commitment to quality.
Conclusion
The decline in the quality of higher education is a multifaceted problem that requires comprehensive reform. Universities must realign their priorities, placing academic excellence above financial considerations. By adopting merit-based admissions, providing adequate support for research, and ensuring accountability at all levels, institutions can cultivate an environment where education thrives. The journey toward quality is challenging but essential for the growth and development of individuals, institutions, and society as a whole.
Read: Time to Address the Toxic Smoke of 2-Stroke Rickshaws in Hyderabad, Sindh
_____________________
The writer is a professor at the Department of Energy and Environment at Sindh Agriculture University, Tandojam, Sindh Pakistan