The Bengalis and the Punjabis: Nation Split by Geography, Hate

0
15
Pakistan-Bangladesh-rethinking Global Village Space
Map courtesy: Global Village Space

The New York Times’ archival report on rift between Bengalis and Punjabis published on December 4, 1970, a year before the Pakistan was dismembered in December 1971       

The New York Times’ Note about the Archive

This is a digitized version of an article from The Times’ print archive, before the start of online publication in 1996. To preserve these articles as they originally appeared, The Times does not alter, edit or update them. Occasionally the digitization process introduces transcription errors or other problems; we are continuing to work to improve these archived versions.

By Sydney H. Schanberg; Special to The New York Times

DACCA, Pakistan, Dec. 1– There is an old Bengali saying: If you come across a Punjabi and a snake, kill the Punjabi first.

The New York Times Archives
The New York Times Archives

A strange adage, perhaps. About two ethnic groups that belong to the same country, Pakistan. But then it is an improbable country. Its two parts, the Bengali East and the Punjabi West, are separated by culture, language, diet, temper ament and more than a thousand miles of the unfriendly territory of India.

The Bengali‐Punjabi feud has been dramatically sharpened by the terrible cyclone and tidal wave that crushed vast coastal areas of East Pakistan on the night of Nov. 12, killing hundreds of thousands of Bengalis and leaving millions ill and hungry and homeless.

The central Government, run from West Pakistan and dominated by the Punjabis, moved sluggishly—on some fronts not at all—to help the survivors. Outraged Bengalis accused West Pakistan of indifference, callousness, criminal negligence and even deliberate murder.

Echo of British Rule

For the Bengalis the Government’s behavior, whether de liberate or not, reinforced in the most tragic manner their belief that West Pakistan has always regarded East Pakistan as nothing but a colony and market for its goods. The Bengalis feel that they have been exploited by West Pakistan much as the British exploited the land before independence and partition in 1947.

PakistanMapPre1971.JPG University of Central Arkansas
Map courtesy: University of Central Arkansas

“The British started the racial domination of Punjabi over Bengali,” a Bengali intellectual said with a sneer the other day. “They liked to talk paternally about the simple, straight forward, martial Punjabis, much better fellows than those nasty, scheming Bengalis.”

It is hard to imagine two races or regions any more different. They speak different languages—Urdu in the West, Bengali in the East—eat different foods—meat and grain in the West, fish and rice in the East—and have almost contradictory cultures, for the Bengalis are volatile and love politics and literature while the Punjabis are more stolid and prefer governing and soldiering.

The only thing the two wings have in common is their religion, Islam. That was the basis for the country’s creation when it was decided that Hindus and Moslems could not live peacefully together and the subcontinent was carved into largely Hindu India and the two Moslem segments that make up Pakistan.

Glue May Lose Its Hold

The glue of Islam may finally be losing its hold. Many observers deem it a miracle that the two regions have stuck together so long and believe that their separation into independent nations is only a matter of time.

National elections will be held next Monday—the first full elections under adult franchise in Pakistan’s history— and East Pakistan is pushing for a form of regional autonomy that many believe is only a prelude to secession.

There has recently been talk that the Government, under pressure from the Punjabi‐run army, is planning to postpone the elections, but fears of popular uprising in East Pakistan have apparently quashed any such intention.

The Bengalis would have regarded postponement as a flimsy pretext for continuing the martial ‐ law regime pro claimed last year, when Gen Agha Mohammad Yahya Khan became President, and with it the domination of the East by the West.

images (3) The Asian Age
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman – Image courtesy: The Asian Age

“If the elections are abort led,” warned Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, leader of the Awami League, the East’s key political party, “The people will owe it to the million who have died in the cyclone to make the supreme sacrifice of another million lives, if need be, so that we can live as a free people. We will no longer suffer the arbitrary rule of the bureaucrats, the capitalists and the feudal interests of West Pakistan.”

Pakistan is that rare country where the majority region is the backward one. Although the East has 75 million people to the West’s 55 million, the West has received the over whelming proportion of the development funds, factories, public‐works projects and defense facilities.

Read: Maulana Bhashani was the first to declare ‘Independence’ of East Pakistan

Prices are higher in East Pakistan, with rice and wheat twice as costly, although per capita income is at least 50 per cent lower. Six times as much electricity is produced in the West, four times as much foreign aid is spent there, three times as many imports are consumed there, twice as much development money is allocated there and nine times as much is spent on defense.

The disparity is heightened, grimly, by the population pressure in East Pakistan, with 20 million more people than in the West in an area only a sixth as large. If the United States had the same density, it would have 4.5 billion people. Broken down, it is more than 1,300 per square mile on the average and as high as 2,100 in cultivated areas.

images (3) X
Results of General Elections held in December 1970, as reported by Pakistan Observer – Image courtesy: X

Perpetual Disaster Area

The pressure, matched only in some parts of Japan, Taiwan and Communist China, has forced the division of farms into smaller and less profitable plots and has pushed hundreds of thousands of the poorest peasants down into the fertile but dangerous lowlands and offshore islands of the Ganges Delta.

Eighty per cent of East Pakistan is less than 50 feet above sea level; the delta areas, even lower, are more vulnerable to storms and monsoon flooding.

East Pakistan is a perpetual disaster area, even in “normal” times—ravaged by cholera, typhoid and smallpox, by pests and filth, by raging unemployment and monsoon floods.

West Pakistan, benefiting from the so‐called green revolution in improved agricultural yields, is just about self‐sufficient in food while East Pakistan has an annual deficit of some 2.5 million tons. Experts say it could be five million tons by 1975, which could mean famine.

Read- Stop the Fight: Don’t Exacerbate the Hatred That Has Kept Indians and Pakistanis Apart for Decades

As if internal problems were not enough, East Pakistan has been far more damaged than was the western sector by the partition, which virtually cut it off from neighboring West Bengal, now a state of India. All trade between them has been forbidden since the brief Indian ‐ Pakistan war over Kashmir in 1965.

The coal that used to come from West Bengal now comes from Communist China at as much as 10 times the cost. The only cement factory in East Pakistan, which used to get its limestone from India, must get it from less economical domestic deposits and pay five times the Indian price.

If the East Pakistanis win a measure of regional autonomy, they will immediately press to improve trade with India, one of the moves feared by the army and the hierarchy of the central Government in West Pakistan.

Generals Are Fearful

The generals know that with greater provincial autonomy, the central Government’s powers would be reduced and the vast military spending, some times as much as half of the budget, would be sharply cut. The army also knows that better relations with India would weaken the arguments for perpetuating the Kashmir dispute, which is one of the main reasons for the army’s existence and has never aroused the Bengalis as it has the Punjabis, who live next to the disputed territory.

Muhammad_Yahya_Khan_1970_Bhola_Cyclone_East_Pakistan
Gen. Muhammad Yahya Khan in 1970 – Wikimedia image

Does the answer to all this woe lie in breaking Pakistan into two nations, as many militant Bengalis and even some Punjabis tired of the crisis now believe? But could East Pakistan, with its overwhelming problems, survive as a separate entity?

The fear of not surviving is what is keeping the dominant Bengali political forces from demanding secession right now.

“If we are the majority, we are Pakistan!” Sheik Mujib thundered at a meeting with the foreign press last week.

Unfortunately for the Bengalis, the army and its powerful friends in West Pakistan do not quite see it that way.

Read: Pakistan: Four in One

_____________

Courtesy: The New York Times (Archives)

 

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here